Both claims are absurd, and can only be held by one who acts like a lawyer who cherry picks google searches to try to build a case versus anyone who examines the facts like a doctor. They examine all facts to determine the best conclusion for their patients.
An honest assessment of facts would start by determining the Covid-19 death rate per capita compared to how many people in each country have pre-existing conditions that would make deaths more likely.
This sheet compares how many deaths each country would expect to have based on the percent of their residents that have diabetes and/or are obese. These are the two most common preconditions. Then the sheet compares that to the actual per capita deaths caused by COVID-19 as of 25 June.
Based on the percent of residents with pre-existing conditions, the fact that 47% of Americans are obese and many have diabetes indicates the US would likely rank 8th in the world in per capita COVID-19 deaths. In fact the US ranks 7th even assuming China and other secretive countries are actually providing accurate death numbers.
One conclusion is many charge that the US response to COVID-19 did not work and that the US is the hardest hit country is absurd. In other words the US per capita COVID-19 death rate is almost exactly what should be expected based on the tremendous number of Americans with pre-existing conditions. The 372 COVID-19 deaths per million is right in line.
On the other extreme, those who refuse to acknowledge the importance of social distancing, wearing masks in public and gradual re-openings long used Sweden as their example of a country that did what the US should have done and simply rode out COVID-19.
However, the Swedes are extremely healthy for a developed country. Barely half as many (25.4%) are obese as Americans, and combined with diabetes or pre-existing conditions project that the Sweden should only rank 82nd in deaths.
In fact Sweden is a disaster. Since the deniers held Sweden up as an example, deaths exploded to 137% of US per capita deaths. They are now fifth in the world with COVID-19 deaths dwarfing those in the US with 512 deaths per million. The two bordering countries have about one-tenth the deaths of Sweden, the country held up as the example of why you should NOT shut down (Norway has 47 deaths per million, and Finland 59).
The second conclusion is now that we know the example of Sweden was a disaster, there is no case left for not wearing masks and ignoring social distancing in order to spread the disease rather than inconvenience ourselves in any way.
The bottom line is that forcing politics into the center of medical debates is a terrible development in the American political scene that costs lives. Those who simply search for ways to blame President Trump or any other politician prevent an effective response just as much as some Trump supporters who try to make a case against taking the simple measures needed like masks and distancing actually make it harder to reopen due to their unwillingness to inconvenience themselves to save lives.
Get the politics out of the process and localities, states and the country can open as much as possible to bring back the lost jobs without escalating deaths that were initially forecast to end next week.
The opinions cited in this article are those of the author alone and do not necessarily represent the opinions of EU Reporter.
Coronavirus: Commission signs contract to procure monoclonal anti-body treatment
Yesterday (27 July), the Commission signed a joint procurement framework contract with the pharmaceutical company Glaxo Smith Kline for the supply of sotrovimab (VIR-7831), an investigational monoclonal antibody therapy, developed in collaboration with VIR biotechnology. It is part of the first portfolio of five promising therapeutics announced by the Commission in June 2021, and is currently under rolling review by the European Medicines Agency. 16 EU member states are participating in the procurement for the purchase of up to 220,000 treatments. Sotrovimab can be used for the treatment of coronavirus patients with mild symptoms who do not require supplemental oxygen, but who are at high risk for severe COVID-19. Ongoing studies suggest that early treatment can reduce the number of patients that progress to more severe forms and require hospitalisation or admission to the intensive care units.
Health and Food Safety Commissioner Stella Kyriakides said: “We committed in our COVID-19 Therapeutics Strategy to have at least three new therapeutics authorised by October. We are now delivering a second framework contract that brings monoclonal antibodies treatments to patients. Alongside vaccines, safe and effective therapeutics will play a pivotal role in Europe's return to a new normal.”
Monoclonal antibodies are proteins conceived in the laboratory that mimic the immune system's ability to fight the coronavirus. They attach to the spike protein and thus block the virus' attachment to the human cells. The European Commission concluded nearly 200 contracts for different medical countermeasures worth over €12 billion.
Under the current framework contract with Glaxo Smith Kline, member states can purchase sotrovimab (VIR-7831) if and when needed, once it has received either emergency use authorisation in the member state concerned or a (conditional) marketing authorisation at EU level from the European Medicines Agency. Further information can be found here.
With vaccines lagging, treatments offer key to stemming India’s COVID death toll
A report by the Washington-based Center for Global Development has revealed that, while official figures set India’s Covid-19 death toll at just over 420,000, the real figure could be up to ten times greater. According to the Center, that would make India the country with the highest coronavirus death toll in the world, far surpassing the United States and Brazil, and would also make the pandemic “arguably India's worst human tragedy since partition and independence", writes Colin Stevens.
Covid-19 deaths have likely been underestimated in Europe as well, with the World Health Organization (WHO) reporting deaths worldwide are likely to be “two to three” times higher than official figures. But in India, four in five deaths were not medically investigated even before the pandemic; now, due to a lack of hospital beds and oxygen, an unknown number of coronavirus sufferers are dying untested and unregistered at home. Widespread social stigma surrounding COVID-19 has compounded this phenomenon, with families often declaring a different cause of death.
While India’s coronavirus infections and deaths have sharply decreased from the peak of the second wave in May, the country has still lost over 16,000 people to Covid since the start of July. Public health experts warn India should brace for a third devastating wave by October, adding urgency to the hunt for tools to help patients who contract severe cases of Covid.
India’s vaccine drive misses targets
Vaccines are the main preventative tool to keep severe infections at bay, and India has already distributed some 430 million doses—more than any other nation after China. Even so, only 6.9% of the Indian population has been fully vaccinated so far, out of a population of 1.4 billion citizens. Since the emergence of the highly contagious Delta variant in October 2020, India’s immunisation drive has been plagued with vaccine shortages, broken supply chains, and vaccine hesitancy.
This month, the WHO announced India will receive 7.5 million doses of the Moderna vaccine via the COVAX facility, but India’s domestic vaccine rollout continues to hit stumbling blocks. Bharat Biotech – who produce the country’s only approved homegrown vaccine, Covaxin – this week projected further delays, making it impossible for India to meet its target of distributing 516 million shots by the end of July.
International disagreement on treatments
With herd immunity still far out of reach, India’s medical services still desperately need effective treatment solutions to help hospitalised patients. Fortunately, life-saving therapeutic options now being tried and tested in Europe could soon offer powerful weapons against the most dangerous infections.
While the number of Covid treatments available are growing as drugs complete clinical trials, global public health bodies are still divided as to which ones are most effective. The only treatment to receive the European Union’s greenlight is Gilead's remdesivir, but the WHO actively advises against that particular antiviral treatment, recommending instead two ‘interleukin-6 receptor blockers’ known as tocilizumab and sarilumab. Tocilizumab has also been proven effective by the wide-ranging RECOVERY trial in the UK, reducing time in hospital and the need for mechanically-assisted breathing.
Despite being a global hub for drug manufacturing, India is not always as quick to approve them. US pharmaceutical company Merck boosted India's manufacturing capacity for the antiviral medicine molnupiravir to help fight the second wave this past April, but local drug trials will not be completed until September at the earliest. In the interim, Indian authorities have awarded emergency approval to a different treatment for Covid-19, 2-DG, despite a lack of published trial data for the molecule.
New treatments like Leukine in the pipeline
This limited set of extant Covid-19 drugs will soon be bolstered by other promising therapies. One such treatment, Partner Therapeutics’ sargramostim – known commercially as Leukine – is currently undergoing testing in both Europe and the United States with a view towards rapid approval. In February, trials led by University Hospital Ghent and bringing together five Belgian hospitals found that Leukine “can significantly improve oxygenation in COVID-19 patients with acute hypoxic respiratory failure,” increasing oxygenation in the majority of patients by at least a third from baseline levels.
After noting Leukine’s potential, the US Department of Defence signed a $35 million contract to fund two Phase 2 clinical trials in order to supplement preliminary data. This past June, the results of the second randomized US trials of inhaled Leukine once again showed positive improvements in the lung functions of patients with the acute hypoxemia caused by severe Covid, confirming the Belgian findings that oxygen levels in patients who had received Leukine were higher than those who did not.
Effective Covid treatments would reduce pressure on Indian healthcare providers not only by improving chances of survival, but also by accelerating recovery times and freeing up hospital beds for other patients, including those dealing with other ailments. Faster treatments would also reduce the dangers posed to patients by contagious conditions such as black fungus, which has already been implicated in the deaths of over 4,300 hospitalised Covid patients in India. Greater clarity and accessibility surrounding treatments would also curb the worrying uptick in Indian families turning to the black market to purchase medical supplies of unknown provenance at hugely inflated prices.
Treatments that improve recovery rates and prevent fatal cases of Covid will remain crucial for as long as most Indians remain unvaccinated. Provided new drugs are approved in a timely manner, improved medical understanding of the virus means new Covid patients should have a better prognosis than ever.
COVID-19 vaccines: Launch of the interactive map on vaccine production capacities in the EU
The Commission has published an interactive map showcasing COVID-19 vaccine production capacities in the EU, along the entire supply chain. The mapping tool is based on data gained through the work of the Task Force for Industrial Scale-up of COVID-19 vaccine production, on data collected during the matchmaking event organised by the Commission in March, as well as publicly available information and information shared by member states. This data will be complemented and updated as further information becomes available.
Commissioner Breton, responsible for the Internal Market and head of the Task Force, said: “With more than one billion vaccine doses produced, our industry has helped the EU become the world's most vaccinated continent and the world's leading exporter of COVID-19 vaccines. This interactive map, featuring hundreds of EU-based manufacturers, suppliers and distributors, shows the breadth of the industrial ecosystem, as well as the potential for new industrial partnerships to further boost our health emergency preparedness.”
The Task Force categorized the companies based on their main area of activity, thus companies may have more capacities than those reflected in the map. The Task Force for Industrial Scale-up of COVID-19 vaccine production was set up by the Commission in February 2021 to ramp up production capacity for COVID-19 vaccines in the EU, acting as a one-stop-shop for manufacturers seeking support, and to identify and address bottlenecks in terms of production capacity and supply chain. The interactive map is available here.
Brexit2 days ago
EU backs Ireland as UK searches for solutions to Northern Ireland Protocol dilemma
EU Reporter3 days ago
Summertime and the livin’ is… not always so easy
coronavirus3 days ago
Ensuring smooth air travel while checking EU Digital COVID Certificates: New guidelines for member states
Energy2 days ago
US and Germany strike Nord Stream 2 pipeline deal to push back on Russian 'aggression'
coronavirus3 days ago
Coronavirus: Commission steps up research funding with €120 million for 11 new projects to tackle the virus and its variants
Kazakhstan1 day ago
Voters go to rural polls for first time in Kazakhstan
coronavirus1 day ago
How the Delta variant upends assumptions about the coronavirus
Brexit2 days ago
UK's Johnson urges EU to consider post-Brexit proposals seriously