Connect with us

European Court of Human Rights (ECHR)

The European Court of Human Rights refuses to prevent the ongoing and severe ill-treatment in detention of children and other vulnerable individuals




The appalling conditions that 101 members of a persecuted religious minority are held under in detention in Turkey, including 22 children and other vulnerable individuals, have just been overlooked by the European Court of Human Rights.

The case which has gained the attention of international media as well as the United Nations
and the EU parliament involves a group of 101 members of the Ahmadi Religion of Peace
and Light who have suffered extreme persecution in their home countries on the basis of their

After being violently prevented from applying for asylum at the Bulgarian border, they
were subjected to extreme violence at the hands of the Turkish border police, they were
subsequently detained and deportation orders were issued against them. In detention, the
group (that includes 22 children aged from 1 to 17, and at least 27 elderly or sick adults)
endured severe beatings and threats of sexual violence from the Turkish gendarmerie, and
ill-treatment, intimidation, and medical neglect in the Edirne removal center.

Following reports of the deteriorating health and psychological conditions of the children, the
group has filed a request for interim measures with the European Court of Human Rights, to
order an independent medical examination of the detained members and an independent
monitoring of their conditions of detention. The request subsequently focused on the need to
release the detained members from detention or, at the very least, the vulnerable individuals
among them.

On 21 July 2023 a letter came from a duty judge of the European Court of Human Rights
informing the group of the court’s decision not to indicate to the Government of Türkiye the
interim measure requested in respect of the applicants’ administrative detention. No
reasoning for this refusal was provided.

The flat and unreasoned refusal by the Court to grant any kind of measure in respect of the
conditions of the Applicants’ detention is in contrast with the ECtHR’s established case law
concerning violations of Article 3 ECHR on conditions of detention, and particularly with the
case law concerning the detention of children, whose vulnerability takes precedence over any
consideration related to their status (e.g. Mubilanzila Mayeka and Kaniki Mitunga v.
Belgium, 2006; Muskhadzhiyeva and Others v. Belgium, 2010; Popov v. France, 2012; A.B.
and Others v. France, 2016; G.B. and Others v. Turkey, 2019), and with general
considerations of fairness and humanity.

The response of the court, in this case, is especially worrying given the pressing nature of
such a case, where children as young as 1 year old are being detained in horrendous
conditions, and in continuing violation of their most basic right.


Furthermore, the Ahmadi Religion of Peace and Light has welcomed at its headquarters
Cheshire East Mayor Rod Fletcher and Crewe Chief Inspector Fez Khan who visited the
premises and discussed with the representatives of the religion the plight of the 101 detained
members of the faith in Turkey and the religious persecution and oppression members of the
faith are enduring worldwide.

Share this article:

EU Reporter publishes articles from a variety of outside sources which express a wide range of viewpoints. The positions taken in these articles are not necessarily those of EU Reporter.