New research: Carmakers manipulate #TyreMonitorTests

New independent research points to carmakers again manipulating official tests – this time on safety by adjusting indirect tyre pressure monitoring systems (TPMS) to pass the lab test but failing to perform on the road. The TPMS are designed to alert the driver when their tyres are deflating or are at a dangerously low pressure, but €10-cheaper indirect systems have failed most of the on-road tests commissioned by green group Transport & Environment (T&E), putting drivers, passengers, pedestrians and cyclists at greater risk of dangerous blow-outs.

Two vehicles with indirect TPMS and under-inflated tyres, a Volkswagen Golf and a Fiat 500L, performed as required in a copy of the narrow type approval test carried out by automotive testing specialists Idiada. But out of 16 real-world tests diverging from the official protocol, the Golf failed 14 and the Fiat all 16. Such indirect systems rely on tyre vibration and wheel rotations to detect low pressure, while the more effective direct TPMS have sensors to accurately measure the pressure in each wheel.

Julia Poliscanova, clean vehicles manager at T&E, said: “With Dieselgate, carmakers were caught wilfully putting the public’s health at risk from poisonous emissions. Now we find manufacturers could be deploying similar defeat devices to get ineffective tyre pressure monitoring systems to pass safety tests and save themselves €10. Investigations of the suspicious TPMS performance must be carried out. Our tests clearly show that the unsafe indirect systems put drivers, pedestrians and cyclists at greater risk of dangerous blow-outs.”

The most suspicious results were obtained when the same regulatory test was repeated on tyres with some mileage; the TPMS failed to alert drivers of tyres’ low pressure. This indicates that the indirect systems were primed to get through official tests but become less sensitive once they were used on the road. Carmakers may be optimizing indirect systems to be less sensitive after the initial test as their detection is based on wheel vibrations and rotations which could be falsely triggered in various real-world conditions like varying road surfaces and temperatures, and cold or slippery weather.

Use of indirect TPMS is growing in Europe, but carmakers utilize them much less in the US where vehicles are tested over their lifetimes. Currently, EU law mandates TPMS but doesn’t differentiate between direct and indirect systems. T&E said that the review of the inadequate performance criteria, as part of the new General Safety Regulation (GSR), should only allow direct systems. The new GSR, set to be proposed by the end of this year, should also require more on-road testing of cars to check their safety performance.

Julia Poliscanova added: “The EU has a unique opportunity to phase out this ineffective safety equipment in its upcoming review of the General Safety Regulation and mandate that TPMS should perform in real-world conditions and with all tyres, including replacement ones. The European Commission should also use current negotiations on the new Type Approval Framework Regulation to ensure tyre pressure monitoring systems are checked over their lifetime on the road by the national market surveillance authorities and the Commission.”

Read more:

T&E report on indirect TPMS and test results

Share this article: