EU Reporter
  • News Categories
    • Featured
    • Politics
    • World
    • Defence
    • Economy
    • Business
    • Energy
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Lifestyle
    • Opinion
    • Google News
    • Animal Welfare
    • Human Rights
  • Latest Videos
  • Featured
  • Collaborate
  • Sponsorship
  • About
  • Team
  • Contact
Connect with us
EU Reporter EU Reporter

EU Reporter

#FriendsofEurope: Beyond the #Robot scare

  • Featured
  • Politics
    • New EU initiatives to tackle desertification and drought

    • Commission adopts Ocean Pact with €1 billion to protect marine life and strengthen blue economy

    • EU backs cutting-edge research with €721 million in funding

    • EU budget continued to deliver on results while the STEP initiative boosted innovation in 2024

    • Executive Vice-President Fitto participates in the Cities Forum 2025 in Kraków

  • World
    • Commission disburses the second payment of €58 million to Luxembourg under NextGenerationEU

    • EU to provide €161 million in humanitarian aid for Afghanistan in 2025

    • Commission proposes to integrate Ukraine into the EU Roaming area in 2026

    • Ukraine receives a further €1 billion G7 loan initiative

    • The European Commission helps boosting Egypt's green transition

  • Economy
    • Recommendations to boost women’s participation in the EU transport sector

    • 2024: €76 billion invested in environmental protection

    • CETA evaluation shows strong economic and social benefits

    • Drone strikes on fertilizer giant NAK Azot threaten Europe’s food security

    • Smart urban mobility takes centre stage at ITS European Congress in Seville

  • Energy
    • Commissioner Jørgensen hosts high-level implementation dialogue on permitting in the clean energy transition

    • European Union and the Latin American Energy Organization sign an important agreement

    • Nearly €1 billion awarded to boost development of renewable hydrogen

    • Household electricity prices in the EU stable in 2024

    • Road map to fully end EU dependency on Russian energy

  • Education
    • AI in Science: Feedback to the consultations on the future strategy shows strong interest from public and scientific community

    • EU continues attracting international students as latest Erasmus Mundus scholarships announced

    • Renewal of the Group of Chief Scientific Advisors

    • EU sets out road map for joint European degree

    • Join the Science4EU campaign

  • Environment
    • Dead dolphins on Russian beaches as Black Sea oil disaster escalates

    • 2024: €76 billion invested in environmental protection

    • Commission assesses nuclear investment needs by 2050 in view of decarbonization and competitiveness goals

    • Wolves in green suits: How environmental commodities traders Bram Bastiaansen and  Jaap Janssen reaped the system

    • Commissioner Hoekstra chairs Implementation Dialogue on the Decarbonization of Buildings and Road Transport

  • Health
    • Illicit cigarette trade surges in France and the Netherlands, raising alarm over policy failures

    • The EU institutions agree to streamline assessments of chemicals in Europe

    • Why Is Europe choosing the longest path to end smoking?

    • Commission invests in the development of innovative products against respiratory viruses

    • Croatia at the frontier of personalized medicine

  • Lifestyle
    • Celebrating the skill, passion, and creativity of mixologists

    • Here’s this year’s fix to UEFA’s multi-club ownership nightmare

    • Why is UEFA punishing a small Irish club while allowing football’s behemoths to bend the rules?

    • Malaysian believer put on trial for believing in Abdullah Hashem

    • Concerts will mark church organ anniversary

  • AI
  • Google News
  • Fact Check
    • Trapped in the feed: How endless scrolling warps our reality and wears us down

    • Separating fact from fiction: The BRICS currency debate

    • How Nigerian news outlets spread disinformation on the Ukraine-Russia conflict

    • Goolammv ‘unmasking’ raises more questions than it answers

    • Nova Resistência in Brazil: Identifying Dangerous Narratives and Stemming Their Influence

  • More
    • Affiliate Sites
      • London Globe
      • New York Globe
      • Globe Nederland
      • Globo Espana
      • Le Globe France
      • Globus Deutschland
      • Globo Diroma
      • Brussels Standard
      • Top Line News
      • News Wire
      • Coin Reporter
    • Animal welfare
      • Contrasting changes in animal production forecast

      • The devil is in the detail: Why Europe needs a comprehensive livestock strategy

      • Without a clear animal vaccination strategy, the next outbreak could be a disaster

      • Dolphinariums to be banned across Belgium

      • Compassion in World Farming calls for improved animal welfare

    • Business
      • EU backs cutting-edge research with €721 million in funding

      • Economic characteristics of enterprises: New insights

      • 2025 State of the Digital Decade report urges renewed action on digital transformation and technological sovereignty

      • The EU sets out its International Digital Strategy

      • Green transformation of the cement industry: Skills that will make it happen

    • Defence
      • A strong call for co-ordinated action against illicit economies in Europe

      • EU member states endorse €150 billion SAFE defence loan instrument to boost European defence capabilities

      • Read-out of the first meeting of the Strategic Dialogue with the European Defence Industry

      • EU extends cyber sanctions regime amid rising digital threats

      • On strengthening cyber offensive capabilities, EU member states cannot wait after Brussels

    • Human Rights
    • Opinion
    • Online TV
    • Online Radio
    • Contact

EU

#FriendsofEurope: Beyond the #Robot scare

SHARE:

Published

7 years ago

on

February 13, 2018

By

Guest Contributor - Opinion

We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. You can unsubscribe at any time.

László Andor

László Andor is a former EU commissioner, now head of department of economic policy (Corvinus University, Budapest), Senior Research Fellow at IMK (Düsseldorf) and Trustee of Friends of Europe.


Fears about number of jobs

The great robot scare of recent years seems to have eased into more sober assessments of the quantitative and qualitative implications of the digitalization and automation revolution (DAR). As opposed to sensationalist predictions that 40% of jobs would disappear over a 10-year period, today we expect less than 10% of jobs to be knocked out completely. The OECD has spearheaded research to put expectations on a sounder footing, which is connected to its preparations for a new jobs strategy to be launched in 2018.

More robots in the economy should logically mean fewer jobs for humans, but surveys of the actual results do not seem to support this conclusion. If we take a comparative approach in Europe, we find that the technologically advanced – that is, highly digitalised and automated – economies are also high-employment societies: Sweden, Denmark and The Netherlands, for example. On the other hand, in countries where the employment rate is low, such as Hungary and Bulgaria, this is not the result of a large number of robots crowding out the workforce from their jobs.

In a global perspective, Japan has advanced robotisation in industry and services but very close to full employment. The country is nowadays demanding that older cohorts remain in the labour market in increasing numbers. Cases like these actually reverse the expected causality. Robots are not emerging for unknown reasons, but because of a shortage of labour due to factors such as high growth, low fertility and modest immigration. Robots are being introduced more intensively in our work and life because we need them and there are many things we could not do without them.

More robots in the economy should logically mean fewer jobs for humans, but surveys of the actual results do not seem to support this conclusion

Advertisement

By and large, this is the reason why prominent labour economists, such as Christopher Pissarides, appear to be intensely relaxed about the net job quantity effects of DAR. There are very few examples where new technology is not both an opportunity and a threat, and policies as well as industrial relations frameworks matter a lot. There is now evidence of an uneven impact of DAR in labour markets that are organised differently. In the US, robotisation did result in large-scale job destruction, but in Germany workers benefitted from this technological trend – including in terms of pay – even though their companies hired fewer young employees. Germany’s overall level of unemployment has actually fallen, even after years of crisis and transformation.

Concerns about sectoral effects and the quality of jobs

More urgent than the impact of digitalisation and automation on the number of jobs is its effect on job quality. This should be addressed in a preventative manner if possible. Governments, in cooperation with the EU, have to monitor sectoral effects and assess and manage the various risks associated with DAR.

Although we also often connect DAR with the concept of Industry 4.0, the transformation is expected to be less marked in industry in the coming years, simply because a huge number of industrial jobs have already been eliminated. The rise of artificial intelligence actually means that professions previously less-affected by technological change could be decimated by the unfolding transformation.

The expected boost to productivity can be offset by the lack of sleep, rest and concentration associated with hyper-connectivity. At the workplace, long hours at keyboards can affect the back, wrist, neck and eyes if no protection is provided, leading to increased health costs. What needs to be prevented most of all is the opening up by DAR of little channels or even avenues out of the social security system, aggravating its current sustainability problems. A general concern throughout the world is whether DAR will further boost social inequality, and a specific European concern is whether it will deepen intra-EU imbalances.

The main reason why DAR scares a lot of people is that it accompanies several recent megatrends. The most important of these are globalisation and flexible work – the rise of atypical forms of employment and the resulting segmentation of labour markets. For many people, these undermine both employment security and income. Hence for many experts, including those discussing the future of work on various fora of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), the question is whether the new wave of technological change can be reconciled with social justice. European trade union leaders speak about a “just transition”, which would need to be supported by a specific fund.

The point is to urgently refresh the content of vocational training and make education in information and communications technology available at all levels

Supporters of a universal basic income (UBI) have started to use DAR as an argument for their favoured simplification of social policy. However, even if DAR does not push us to adopt UBI schemes in the foreseeable future, social security still needs to adapt in every economic cycle, and this one is no exception. Gig workers should not be allowed to remain without health care and pensions, but new branches of the welfare state might also emerge from the new forms of employment.

Agenda for digital era labour market

More education and skills are at the top of every policy response to economic and social challenges, but in this case they are just the beginning of the list. The point is to urgently refresh the content of vocational training and make education in information and communications technology available at all levels and in all age categories.

Highly skilled information engineers are only the tip of the iceberg. The transition has to be made by many people, and the circle of digital professionals is going to be much wider. Projects like Codecool in Central Europe demonstrate how cooperation between businesses and future employees can provide upskilling for the transition.

Policy responses have to be inclusive. Pioneering studies in Germany have been based on workforce surveys and consultation with social partners about their expectations regarding DAR and the reforms that will be needed. Governments need to be attentive to potential job destruction, but filling vacancies for employees with the right skill sets is a more pressing issue in most countries.

In Europe, the promotion of technological change has to be accompanied by a policy for territorial cohesion in order to counterbalance the tendency to form information technology clusters. This seems to be aggravated by the ease with which professionals in that field migrate. Knowledge-transfer strategies have to accompany resource transfers, because DAR represents a general risk to countries whose economic development has been based on assembly or other manufacturing activities. With more robots, production may move closer to large markets, and “reshoring” may turn from hope to reality. Also, DAR is a greater threat to some countries than others, making an additional reason to forge a more intimate relationship between industrial and regional policies in the EU.

Share this article:

Related Topics:Featuredfull-imageRobroborobotrobotsUBIuniversal basic income
EU Reporter publishes articles from a variety of outside sources which express a wide range of viewpoints. The positions taken in these articles are not necessarily those of EU Reporter. Please see EU Reporter’s full Terms and Conditions of publication for more information EU Reporter embraces artificial intelligence as a tool to enhance journalistic quality, efficiency, and accessibility, while maintaining strict human editorial oversight, ethical standards, and transparency in all AI-assisted content. Please see EU Reporter’s full A.I. Policy for more information.
Up Next

#WorldRadioDay 2018: A day to celebrate the power of radio

Don't Miss

#FriendsofEurope: The European Parliament’s dilemma - is the rejection of transnational voting lists compatible with its democratic aspirations?

Advertisement

You may like

  • New EU initiatives to tackle desertification and drought

  • Recommendations to boost women’s participation in the EU transport sector

  • Celebrating the skill, passion, and creativity of mixologists

  • Popular
  • Latest
  • Videos
Anti-semitism4 days ago

Antisemitic incitement: Posters with names and photos of Jewish personalities displayed in Brussels with the accusation: ‘He/She lobbies for genocide.’

Africa4 days ago

AfDB: Challenges in a historic context for Sidi Ould Tah

Artificial intelligence3 days ago

Generative AI set to transform EU economy but requires further policy action

Decarbonization4 days ago

Commission assesses nuclear investment needs by 2050 in view of decarbonization and competitiveness goals

China-EU5 days ago

From father to son: The enduring values guiding Xi Jinping

Health3 days ago

Illicit cigarette trade surges in France and the Netherlands, raising alarm over policy failures

Ireland4 days ago

Right-thinking football fans should hope CAS saves tiny Drogheda United from UEFA’s clutches

Egypt4 days ago

The European Commission helps boosting Egypt's green transition

European Commission10 minutes ago

New EU initiatives to tackle desertification and drought

Economy40 minutes ago

Recommendations to boost women’s participation in the EU transport sector

Leisure1 hour ago

Celebrating the skill, passion, and creativity of mixologists

Maritime2 hours ago

Commission adopts Ocean Pact with €1 billion to protect marine life and strengthen blue economy

Luxembourg23 hours ago

Commission disburses the second payment of €58 million to Luxembourg under NextGenerationEU

Horizon Europe24 hours ago

EU backs cutting-edge research with €721 million in funding

Afghanistan1 day ago

EU to provide €161 million in humanitarian aid for Afghanistan in 2025

Research1 day ago

EU backs cutting-edge research with €721 million in funding

Ukraine2 months ago

Shevtsova’s case: Out-of-court sanctions dismantling trust in Ukrainian cause

Transport2 months ago

The future of European transport

Politics3 months ago

Trump Vs Trueman

US3 months ago

US 'no longer' an 'unconditional ally' for Europe - MEP

US3 months ago

MEP warns tariffs could cause 'huge disruption'

Economy3 months ago

US tariffs could have 'grave' consequences, warns Irish MEP

Pakistan8 months ago

Call for decisive action on human rights violations in Pakistan

Greece9 months ago

Delphos advises ONEX Elefsis Shipyards and Industries SA (“ONEX”) on$125 million loan for Greek shipyard rehabilitation

  • 6,628Followers
  • 4,936Likes

Trending

  • Anti-semitism4 days ago

    Antisemitic incitement: Posters with names and photos of Jewish personalities displayed in Brussels with the accusation: ‘He/She lobbies for genocide.’

  • Africa4 days ago

    AfDB: Challenges in a historic context for Sidi Ould Tah

  • Artificial intelligence3 days ago

    Generative AI set to transform EU economy but requires further policy action

  • Decarbonization4 days ago

    Commission assesses nuclear investment needs by 2050 in view of decarbonization and competitiveness goals

EU Reporter
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookies Policy
  • AI Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Contact

Copyright © 2025 EU Reporter. All rights reserved.