Connect with us

EU

Muddy waters in the #Yukos case

SHARE:

Published

on

We use your sign-up to provide content in ways you've consented to and to improve our understanding of you. You can unsubscribe at any time.

mikhail-khodorkovsky-i12Rarely does a normally tedious international arbitration case rise to cult status and become shorthand for the ills of an entire country. But such was the destiny of the Yukos case, which involved the alleged illegal, politically motivated appropriation of Russia’s largest oil company by the Russian state and the subsequent jailing of its owner and chairman, Mikhail Khodorkovsky (pictured), writes Henry St George.

Since its start in 2005, the legal drama has captured and polarized legal experts, political watchers and the general public alike, who have pored over the byzantine set of rules and incidents that led to a court in the Hague to award the company’s shareholders a record-breaking $50 billion in 2014.

Labeled by many in the West as political victims of the Putin regime, former Yukos shareholders launched a slew of suits, trying to recover their lost assets by asking courts in several jurisdictions to freeze Russian assets. But this feeding frenzy didn’t last long. Earlier this year, a Dutch court delivered a surprising reversal of fortunes when it quashed the 2014 award, overturning the decision over procedural grounds. The Permanent Court of Arbitration ruled that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the case because it was brought under the Energy Charter Treaty, which has never been ratified by Russia.

And in late November, the Appeals Court of Paris dealt another blow to Yukos shareholders after it decided to unfreeze several assets of the Russian state that had been put aside as part of the $50 billion award. With the suit falling apart, hopes are rising that the 22-yearlong saga will finally come to an end, silencing the noise and misinformation that has accompanied Khodorkovsky and his clique. 

Advertisement

Beyond its procedural aspects, which are mainly of interest to a select class of legal insiders, what is most perplexing about the Yukos case is the overnight metamorphosis of one of Russia’s most fearsome oligarchs and powerbrokers into a human rights champion of a stature not seen since the days of Andrei Sakharov and Alexandr Solzhenitsyn. 

This is not cheap hyperbole – many hoped Khodorkovsky would win the Nobel Peace Prize in 2011 for his courageous opposition to lawlessness and corruption in Russia. But what is the Yukos founder, if not a product of those very same conditions? His rise to greatness was littered with corruption accusations, venal behavior and even murder. And while he is now bemoaning Russia’s failed transition to democracy from the comfort of his London home, the stark disconnect between his words and his past actions is just too great to simply sweep under the rug.

It’s worth remembering that before Khodorkovsky was sent to prison for fraud, embezzlement and money laundering, thus being anointed by Western groups as a “prisoner of conscience”, he was the embodiment of the corrupt Russian state of the early 1990s. A former member of the Komsomol (the All-Union Leninist Young Communist League), the future Yukos founder rose to prominence after his Bank Menatep propped up the cash-strapped government of Boris Yeltsin, thereby landing a front-row seat during the privatization of state-owned assets. Menatep went on to buy Yukos, one of the biggest oil companies, for a pitiful $300. As the New York Times documented in 1996, “Foreign investors were barred from bidding for the most desirable assets, and the same banks that were assigned by the Government to organize the auctions ended up winning them, and usually at only a fraction over the minimum bid.”

Advertisement

With Yukos in the bag, Khodorkovsky’s stature and influence in Russian state affairs began to grow. As early as 1999, Khodorkovsky was being investigated by Russian securities regulators for using offshore entities to illegally evade paying taxes in the country. U.S authorities also caught on to the web of corruption that was spun by Yukos and started investigating the company for money laundering to the tune of $10 billion – the biggest such case in American history. At the time, the case raised questions about Western institutions’  susceptibility to the enablement of corrupt activities: a senior Vice President of the Bank of New York used by Khodorkovsky for his dealings was married to the vice chairman of Yukos. 

But perhaps the most egregious string of accusations that should have dampened the West’s sanctification of Khodorkovsky is the trail of dead bodies left behind by individuals associated with Yukos. The mayor of Siberian oil capital Nefteyugansk, Vladimir Petukhov, was executed mob-style in 1998 by a local criminal syndicate with ties to Alexei Pichugin, the company’s chief security officer, and Leonid Nevzelin, a major Yukos shareholder. Pichugin was also charged and convicted for asking an associate, Sergei Gorin, to set up a failed contract killing of Olga Kostina, an employee of Group Menatep. The prosecution found Pichugin had Gorin and his wife killed, after the latter threatened to expose the plot to the authorities. 

A separate court case found that Pichugin was acting on the orders of Nevzelin, and in 2015, Khodorkovsky was also connected to the killings. On top of that, the Yukos owner was charged with the attempted killing of businessman Yevgeny Rybin in 1999. It seems that Petukhov was targeted because he had been trying to recover unpaid taxes Yukos owed the state.

Not even company employees were safe. Stephen Curtis, a millionaire British lawyer who created the complex tax haven structure meant to shield Yukos’ assets from the taxman, died in a freak helicopter accident. At the time of his death, Curtis was the only director of the company that controlled 50% of Yukos and was entrusted with managing Khodorkovsky’s assets while the latter was serving his 9-year sentence for fraud and embezzlement. 

While it is not for us to dispense justice – we can leave that to the courts - the circumstances surrounding Yukos’ rise and fall fail the stink test. With so many lives destroyed by the savage Russian capitalism of the 1990s at the hand of a motley group of self-serving oligarchs, the elevation of Khodorkovsky to his current victim status should therefore be taken with a grain of salt. After all, he who lives by the sword, dies by the sword.

Share this article:

Belgium

Clashes break out in Brussels in protests over coronavirus restrictions

Published

on

By

Police and protesters clashed in the streets of Brussels on Sunday (21 November) in demonstrations over government-imposed COVID-19 restrictions, with police firing water cannon and tear gas at demonstrators throwing rocks and smoke bombs, witnesses said, write Christian Levaux, Johnny Cotton and Sabine Siebold, Reuters.

About 35,000 people took part in demonstrations, police said, which began peacefully before violence broke out.

Protesters wearing black hoods threw stones at police as they advanced with water cannon at the main junction in front of the European Union Commission headquarters, Reuters journalists said.

Facing up to the police lines, the protesters held hands and chanted "freedom". One protester was carrying a placard reading "when tyranny becomes law, rebellion becomes duty".

Advertisement
Police forces stand guard as people protest against coronavirus disease (COVID-19) measures near the European Commission in Brussels, Belgium November 21, 2021. REUTERS/Johanna Geron

Protesters also threw smoke bombs and fireworks, the newspaper Le Soir reported. The situation calmed down later, police said.

Belgium tightened its coronavirus restrictions on Wednesday (17 November), mandating wider use of masks and enforcing work from home, as cases rose in the country's fourth COVID-19 wave. Read more.

There have been 1,581,500 infections and 26,568 coronavirus-related deaths reported in the country of 11.7 million people since the pandemic began. Infections are increasing again, with 13,826 new cases reported on average each day.

Advertisement

Violence has also broken out in anti-restriction protests in Belgium's neighbour the Netherlands in recent days. On Friday, police in Rotterdam opened fire on a crowd.

Share this article:

Continue Reading

European Commission

NextGenerationEU: Commission receives payment request from Spain for €10 billion under the Recovery and Resilience Facility

Published

on

The Commission has received the first payment request from Spain under the Recovery and Resilience Facility (RRF) for a disbursement of €10 billion in financial support (net of pre-financing). Spain's overall recovery and resilience plan will be financed by €69.5 billion in grants. Payments under the RRF are performance-based and contingent on Spain implementing the investments and reforms outlined in its recovery and resilience plan. This first payment request relates to 52 milestones covering several reforms in the areas of sustainable mobility, energy efficiency, decarbonisation, connectivity, public administration, skills, education and social, labour and fiscal policy.

The Commission now has two months to assess the request. It will then send its preliminary assessment of Spain's fulfilment of the milestones and targets required for this payment to the Council's Economic and Financial Committee. More information on the process of the payment requests under the RRF is available in this Q&A. More information on the Spanish recovery and resilience plan is available here.

Share this article:

Continue Reading

Belgium

'When the Smurfs meet Monkey King'

Published

on

'When the Smurfs meet Monkey King' is a children's art exhibition celebrating the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and Belgium.

The successful art exhibition celebrating the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and Belgium in La Louvière, the birthplace of Surrealism in Belgium that ended on 24 October gave the opportunity to nearly 300 local primary and middle school students in just one week to depict their vision of friendship between China and Belgium.

On 17 October, during the opening ceremony, Françoise Ghiot, Laurent Wimlot, aldermen of La Louvière, and their guests from China and Belgium attended the event. Counsellor Yang Qing, wife of the Chinese Ambassador to Belgium, also recorded a video for the inauguration of the event.

Counsellor Yang Qing said in her speech that she admired the exhibition held in La Louvière. Using pure and innocent artistic perspective, extraordinary creativity and imagination, the children have well defined the cultural elements of both countries. Celebrating the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and Belgium with children’s eyes, sincere feelings, those future ambassadors of friendship have expressed their visions of a better collaborative future between the two nations.

Advertisement

Ghiot said in her speech that she was very happy on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic relations between China and Belgium to see children’s paintings from China. The art exhibition opened a skylight of artistic exchange for local children.

This children's art exhibition was jointly curated by the city of La Louvière, the Nardone Gallery, and Yellow Vitamines. Through the LPGA (Little Painter Global International Art Exhibition), covering 40 cities and 500 aesthetic education training institutions in China, 5000 children’s work were collected and 200 were finally selected to focus on Belgium. With the innocent help of children's brushes, imagination and understanding, art and culture provided an ideal medium to understanding differences and strengthening the bond between China and Belgium.

Advertisement

Share this article:

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Advertisement

Trending