Excessive corporate influence over policy-making remains a serious threat to the public interest across Europe and at the EU level, warns a new report published by the Alliance for Lobbying Transparency and Ethics Regulation in the EU (ALTER-EU).
Whether avoiding regulation or increasing public funding for corporate activities: lobbying; the revolving door between business and politics; strategic pitches of corporate ‘expertise’; as well as privileged access to decision-makers and corporations’ threats to leverage their structural economic power continue to be highly effective tools used by big business to ensure decision-makers prioritise the profit interests of corporations over vital public needs.
The report includes eight case studies from the EU level and member states showing where the influence of corporations has been so extensive that it constitutes corporate capture. The cases have been investigated and written by NGOs and researchers around Europe. They touch upon various areas of policy-making, including:
- Financial policy (EU level): a banking industry that has mostly managed to avoid stricter regulation despite causing a gigantic financial crisis with devastating economic consequences,
- Security policy (EU level): an arms industry that has increasingly been setting the agenda and objectives of the EU’s defence programmes, ensuring further militarisation but also increasing the public funding of its lethal business
- Emissions regulation (DE): Volkswagen’s success in mobilising the German government to cushion any real regulatory fallout from the Dieselgate scandal
- Corporate taxation (NL): the corporate derailing of plans to tax dividends in the Netherlands at the hands of Shell and Unilever
ALTER-EU coordinator Claudio Cesarano said: “Dieselgate and the failure to regulate the financial industry after the crash have clearly shown that the influence of big business often goes beyond simple lobbying, either actively or passively aided by decision-makers. This is an extreme but unfortunately common threat to the public interest, social security, the environment and public health.”
Myriam Douo, campaigner for ALTER-EU member organization Friends of the Earth Europe said: “Corporate capture is dangerous for our society. Its devastating consequences can be seen in many different policy areas. Threatening EU standards on public health and the environment through trade agreements, by allowing corporations to avoid paying fair taxes and by exposing citizens to more extreme risks from the financial sector. All of this because corporate profits have been prioritized over the public interest.”
Nina Katzemich, campaigner for ALTER-EU member organization Lobbycontrol, added: “The EU Parliament elections are around the corner, so it’s a very good time to put the fight against excessive corporate power firmly on the political agenda. More transparency and stricter ethics rules are important but ultimately, we need a radical change in the way policy-makers at all levels interact with businesses. The needs and demands of citizens must take absolute priority.
- The Alliance for Lobbying Transparency and Ethics Reform (ALTER-EU) is a coalition of over 200 European NGOs and trade unions.
- Read Corporate Capture in Europe : When Big Business Dominates Policy-Making and Threatens Our Rights in full here.
- Short German version here.
- Hard copies of the report are available on request, please email or call us.
- Full list of cases studies included in the report:
- The Banking Sector – Kenneth Haar, Corporate Europe Observatory
- Trade Policy and the Case of TTIP – Paul De Clerck, Friends of the Earth Europe
- The Gas Industry – Myriam Douo, Friends of the Earth Europe
- Tax Policy in the Netherlands – Jasper van Teeffelen, Lobbywatch
- The Pharmaceutical Industry – Rachel Tansey, Freelance writer and researcher
- Data Protection and Privacy Policies - Léa Caillère Falgueyrac, Freelance researcher
- The Arms Industry - Bram Vranken, Vredesactie
- Dieselgate and the German Car Industry - Nina Katzemich, Lobbycontrol
- The publication was launched on 25 September More information here.
COVID-19 vaccines: EU must respond with unity and solidarity
MEPs expressed broad support for the common EU approach to fighting the pandemic and called for complete transparency regarding contracts and deployment of COVID-19 vaccines.
In the plenary debate on Tuesday (19 January), MEPs exchanged views with Ana Paula Zacarias, Portuguese Secretary of State for European Affairs, and Stella Kyriakides, EU Commissioner for Health and Food Safety.
A large majority of MEPs showed their support for the united EU approach, which ensured vaccines are being developed quickly and secured access to vaccines for all European citizens. At the same time, they deplored “health nationalism”, including alleged parallel contracts signed by member states or attempts to outcompete each other. In order to uphold the European success story, the EU must respond with unity and solidarity, with all levels of government working together, say MEPs.
Members called for the terms of contracts between the EU and pharmaceutical companies involving public money to be completely transparent. Recent efforts by the Commission, to allow MEPs to consult one incomplete contract, were deemed insufficient. MEPs reiterated that only complete transparency could help combat disinformation and build trust in the vaccination campaigns across Europe.
Speakers also acknowledged the global dimension of the COVID-19 pandemic, which requires global solutions. The EU has a responsibility to use its position of strength to support its most vulnerable neighbours and partners. The pandemic can be overcome only once all people have equal access to vaccines, not only in rich countries, MEPs added.
The debate also touched upon other issues, such as the need for comparable national data and mutual recognition of vaccinations, the need to avoid delays and increase the speed of vaccination, as well as the unconstructive nature of blaming the EU or the pharmaceutical industry for any failures.
Watch the video recording of the debate here. Click on the names below for individual statements.
Ana Paula Zacarias, Portuguese Presidency
Stella Kyriakides, EU Commissioner for Health and Food Safety
Esther de Lange, EPP, NL
Iratxe García Pérez, S&D, ES
Dacian Cioloş, Renew Europe, RO
Joëlle Mélin, ID, FR
Philippe Lamberts, Greens/EFA, BE
Joanna Kopcińska, ECR, PL
Marc Botenga, The Left, BE
The Commission published an additional communication on the EU’s COVID-19 strategy on 19 January. EU leaders will debate the pandemic state of play during the European Council meeting on 21 January.
On 22 September 2020, Parliament held a public hearing on “How to secure access to COVID-19 vaccines for EU citizens: clinical trials, production and distribution challenges”. During the December 2020 Plenary session, Parliament expressed support for the speedy authorization of safe vaccines and on 12 January 2021, MEPs blamed a lack of transparency for fuelling uncertainty and disinformation regarding COVID-19 vaccination in Europe.
'Brexit carnage': Shellfish trucks protest in London over export delays
Many fishermen have been unable to export to the EU since catch certificates, health checks and customs declarations were introduced at the start of this year, delaying their deliveries and prompting European buyers to reject them.
Trucks with slogans such as “Brexit carnage” and “incompetent government destroying shellfish industry” parked metres from Johnson’s 10 Downing Street office in central London. Police were asking the truck drivers for details.
“We strongly feel the system could potentially collapse,” said Gary Hodgson, a director of Venture Seafoods, which exports live and processed crabs and lobsters to the EU.
“Prime Minister Boris Johnson needs to be honest with us, with himself and with the British public about the problems for the industry,” he told Reuters. One operator, he said, needed 400 pages of export documentation last week to enter Europe.
David Rosie at DR Collin & Son, which employs 200 people, used to send one or two trucks a night to France carrying live crab, lobster and langoustine worth around 150,000 pounds ($203,000). He said he had not exported a single box this year.
Fishermen, he said, “lost their livelihoods in the turn of a clock” when Britain left the EU’s orbit on New Year’s Eve.
Under a deal reached last month, British trade with the EU remains free of tariffs and quotas. But the creation of a full customs border means goods must be checked and paperwork filled in, shattering express delivery systems.
Using a phrase that has angered many business owners, Johnson described the changes as “teething problems”, and said they had been exacerbated by the COVID-19 pandemic.
Johnson said an additional £23 million ($31.24m) fund had been created to compensate businesses that “through no fault of their own have experienced bureaucratic delays, difficulties getting their goods through where there is a genuine buyer on the other side of the channel”.
The government said this extra cash was on top of a £100m investment in the industry over the next few years and nearly £200m provided to the Scottish government to minimize disruption.
Britain’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) said that as well as financial support, it was working with the industry and the EU to address documentation issues.
“Our priority is to ensure that goods can continue to flow smoothly to market,” a government spokesperson said in an emailed statement.
Fishing alone contributes 0.1% of Britain’s GDP if processing is included, but for coastal communities it is a lifeline and a traditional way of life.
The Scotland Food & Drink association says exporters could be losing more than 1 million pounds in sales a day.
Many in coastal communities voted for Brexit but said they had not expected this impact.
Allan Miller, owner of AM Shellfish in Aberdeen, Scotland, said times for his deliveries of live brown crab, lobster and prawns had doubled from 24 hours. This mean lower prices and some of the product did not survive, he said.
“You’re talking 48 hours to 50 hours. It’s crazy,” he said.
Commission takes further steps to foster the openness, strength and resilience of Europe's economic and financial system
Von der Leyen praises Joe Biden's message of healing
Europol supports Spain and US in dismantling money-laundering organized crime
GSK vaccines laboratory acquired by Nexelis
European Greens welcome Biden as president
Reaching the goals of the Paris Agreement
Romania city of Timisoara becomes European Capital of Culture in 2023
Bank embraces blockchain to facilitate Belt and Road trade
#EBA - Supervisor says the EU banking sector entered the crisis with solid capital positions and improved asset quality
The war in #Libya - a Russian movie reveals who is spreading death and terror
First president of #Kazakhstan Nursultan Nazarbayev’s 80th birthday and his role in international relations
EU solidarity in action: €211 million to Italy to repair the damage of the harsh weather conditions in autumn 2019
PKK’s involvement in the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict would jeopardize European security
Von der Leyen praises Joe Biden's message of healing
European Commission launches New European Bauhaus
International observers declare Kazakh elections 'free and fair'
EU reaches agreement to purchase 300 million additional doses of BioNTech-Pfizer vaccine
Commission chief spokesperson reassures vaccine roll-out on track
EU signs Trade and Co-operation Agreement with the UK
Central African Republic (CAR)3 days ago
Tensions in Central Africa: Forcible recruitment, killings and looting among rebels' confessions
Frontpage3 days ago
New US president: How EU-US relations could improve
coronavirus3 days ago
EU lagging on vaccination efforts
coronavirus2 days ago
Coronavirus response: €45 million to support Opolskie region in Poland in fighting the pandemic
US3 days ago
Xiaomi in US crosshairs over military links
Economy3 days ago
European Commission launches New European Bauhaus
Brexit3 days ago
Scottish fishermen land fish in Denmark to avoid post-Brexit red tape
coronavirus3 days ago
Latest on worldwide spread of the coronavirus